This page is for the founder of an established company in Miami or South Florida where two people on the leadership team have stopped working together. It might be the sales lead and the operations lead, finance and operations, a long-serving manager and a newer hire, or a family member and a manager from outside the family. Each of them comes to you separately with their side. In the weekly meeting they avoid each other's items or argue about them, and the work that passes between their functions slows down. Our guide to who sits on the leadership team asks every member to disagree inside the meeting and carry out the decision once it is made. This page covers what to do when two members stop doing that with each other.

Is it a conflict, or the disagreement a leadership team needs?

Two leaders who argue hard about a decision while it is open are doing their job. A sales lead who pushes for an earlier delivery date and an operations lead who pushes back on capacity are each speaking for their function, and the decision is better for hearing both. The weekly meeting exists to settle arguments of that kind.

It has become a conflict when the argument outlives the decision. Signs to look for:

  • The same disagreement returns after the team has decided it with no new information, or one of them works around the decision.
  • One of them holds up work the other needs, such as information, approvals or staff time.
  • Each brings complaints about the other to you privately, and rarely raises them with the other person.
  • Their teams repeat the dispute, and people below them pick sides.
  • Remarks in meetings turn to the other person's character or motives.

One of these on its own may be a bad week. Several of them together, recurring, mean the two have stopped settling their differences through the meeting, and the founder has to act. A leader with new information can still ask for a decision to be reopened, through the issues list and in front of the team.

What is the conflict usually about?

Start from the work. Carlos wrote a line about sales teams that applies to two leaders in the same order: "Evolution requires honest assessment of the system first, not the salesperson." Between two leaders, the system is the function map, the handoffs between functions, the scorecard and the founder's own instructions. Check those before you decide that either person is the problem, because a conflict with a structural cause comes back with whoever holds the two roles next.

CauseTypical signsWhere it gets fixed
Both believe they own the same function or decisionBoth give instructions to the same people, or both expect to approve the same thing.The function map: one owner for the function, with the decision recorded against that owner.
A handoff between their functions that nobody ownsSales commits a date or a scope that operations learns about afterwards. Finance chases information that operations does not know it owes.A written process for the handoff, with one owner and the point where the work passes from one function to the other.
Measures that pull against each otherOne is measured on volume and the other on margin, collections or capacity, so each is right by their own number.The weekly scorecard: agree which number governs the shared decision, or add a measure both answer for.
A shared resource with no ruleBoth draw on the same people, budget, equipment or schedule, and each believes the other takes too much.An allocation rule set by the founder or the general manager, written down and checked at the quarterly review.
A decision only the founder can make is still openThey are arguing about direction or priority, which neither has the authority to settle.The founder decides and tells both at once, using the vision and the quarter's priorities.
Contradictory instructions from the founderEach is following something you said, and the two instructions conflict.You correct your own instructions, to both of them at the same time.
A family or ownership relationship behind the disputeThe dispute between a relative or co-owner and a manager carries a disagreement within the family or among the owners.Family matters go to the family's own forum and ownership matters to the owners or the board, outside the leadership meeting. Any change to who decides what is then confirmed on the function map.
BehaviorThe structure is clear, and one or both still work around decisions, hold back information or make personal remarks.A one-to-one conversation about the role's expectations, and a people decision reviewed with your HR adviser or employment attorney if it continues.
Possible harassment, discrimination, threats, retaliation or a safety concernA complaint or report of conduct of this kind, from either leader or from anyone else.Your HR adviser or employment attorney at once, through the company's complaint process. Keep it separate from the work dispute.

Check every row, because more than one cause can apply. A handoff nobody owns can sit on top of measures that pull apart, and a structural cause left long enough can turn personal. Fix the structural rows first, because behavior is easier to judge once each person knows what they own. Disputes rooted in the family are covered in our guide to professionalizing a family business, and co-owners whose roles have drifted apart in our guide to buying out a business partner.

How does the founder add to it without meaning to?

In a founder-led company, many of these causes start with the founder. Roles were handed out one at a time over years, often to whoever was available, and two people ended up with overlapping work that nobody redrew. The founder may still give instructions directly to people inside another leader's function, so the leader learns about a change after it has happened.

Another cause is the founder acting as the go-between. Each leader brings their side to the founder privately. The founder rules on each complaint separately, and each leader leaves with a different understanding of what was decided. The two then act on two versions of the same decision, and the next complaint arrives.

A simple check: count how many times this month each of them came to you about the other, and how many of those conversations included both of them. If most were private, you have been settling the conflict one side at a time, and that is the first thing to change.

Correct your own part with both of them present before you ask either to change. Say which assignments overlapped and which instruction now applies, and if you reversed a decision in a private conversation, tell both leaders what you changed.

What should the founder do first?

  1. Stop carrying messages. When one of them complains about the other, ask whether they have raised it with the other person. An ordinary disagreement about the work goes on the leadership meeting's issues list or into a meeting with both of them. If it may be a complaint about someone's conduct, speak to your HR adviser or employment attorney first. Listen when someone needs to be heard, and decline to act on one side's account alone.
  2. Meet each of them one to one. Ask for specific examples: what happened, when, what it cost the work and what they need from the other person. Ask each what they think the other would say. Record the examples without deciding whose account is correct. If a complaint comes up, ask your HR adviser or employment attorney how to keep the records and who should look into it, including someone independent if the complaint involves you.
  3. Check the structure. Take the examples to the function map, the process between their functions, the scorecard and your own recent instructions, and look for the causes in the table above.
  4. Meet both together on the work question. Bring the cause you found, written as a decision about the work. Each states their view and what they need. The meeting ends with a decision, an owner and a date, or with one person asked to gather the missing facts by a set date and the issue left open until then.

You can require professional conduct from both of them while you look for the cause. Personal attacks stop now, whatever the structural cause turns out to be. If either of them raises harassment, discrimination, threats, retaliation or safety at any point, stop and speak to your HR adviser or employment attorney before you go further.

How do you settle it in the weekly meeting?

Once the cause is a work question that affects responsibilities or commitments beyond the two of them, it belongs on the weekly leadership meeting's issues list like any other issue. The Founder Blueprint's weekly cadence page gives the issues segment most of the hour: list every issue, rank the top three and solve them one at a time, most important first. Its rule is that a solved issue ends in an owned commitment. Our guide to running the weekly leadership meeting covers how an issue is worked until it is settled.

Write the issue as the work, without names, such as "Delivery dates are quoted before operations confirms capacity." Colleagues can work on an issue written that way without being asked to judge either person, and any judgment about a person belongs in a one-to-one conversation.

Settle who decides before the discussion starts. A decision inside one function belongs to that function's owner, within the limits the team has agreed, after hearing the other leader. Decisions the founder has reserved go to the founder. A decision that crosses functions, such as a handoff or a shared measure, goes to the person with authority over both, often the founder or a general manager, after both have been heard. The other members take part as members of the team, and nobody asks them to choose between their colleagues.

Stop personal remarks when they happen. Bring the discussion back to the issue on the list, and take any comment about a person's character or motives to a private conversation after the meeting. Record the decision with its owner and date. For the delivery-date example, the decision might be that operations confirms capacity before sales quotes a date, with the general manager deciding exceptions. Record who puts the rule in place, when it starts and how a missed confirmation will be spotted, and name who decides urgent customer commitments until it is running. Both leaders then carry it out, including with their own teams, and the commitment is reviewed done or not done the following week. Give the people in both teams the same account of how the work will now proceed, so neither team hears a version that favors its own leader.

A work question that touches only the two of them can be settled in a meeting with both, and recorded the same way. Bring it to the weekly meeting when it changes responsibilities or commitments the rest of the team relies on.

What if the structure is fixed and the conflict continues?

First check that the change took effect. Ownership can be clear on the map while people in both teams still receive contradictory instructions, or a handoff can have an owner who lacks the authority to settle it.

If the change is working in practice, the question is how one or both of them perform the role. Meet each of them separately, and use the expectations every member of the leadership team has agreed to: raise objections while a decision is open, carry it out once it is made, weigh decisions for the company and keep commitments to colleagues. Give specific recent examples, say what has to change and set a date to review it. Have your HR adviser review the conversation beforehand if it may lead to a change in the person's role.

Judge each person on their own conduct. Treating both the same by default can feel fair, and it often leaves the person who kept to the agreements carrying the same warning as the person who did not. When one person is responsible for most of the conflict, the founder has to say so to that person.

If the behavior continues after the review date, review the evidence and the next step with your HR adviser or employment attorney before you decide on discipline or a change to the role, and follow the company's employment process. Our guide to the quarter's people decisions covers how a planned move is owned. An urgent matter is dealt with when it arises.

Avoid splitting a function or redrawing reporting lines only to keep the two apart. The separation can create a new handoff between them, and the work at that handoff can become the next dispute. Change the structure when the work calls for it.

When does the founder need outside help?

  • An independent facilitator for the two of them, when they cannot discuss the work productively even with you present, or when you are part of the cause and cannot chair the conversation neutrally. Agree with both what the facilitator is for and who sees any notes.
  • Leadership team coaching, when the problem has spread beyond two people and the whole team disagrees about the company's situation. Our guide to leadership team coaching or a peer advisory group covers that decision.
  • Your HR adviser or employment attorney, for any complaint, investigation, discipline or change to someone's role.
  • The other owners, when the dispute carries a disagreement among the owners, settled between you before it reaches the leadership meeting.
  • Your own adviser or peer group, to think through the decision before you act, especially when one of the two is a relative or has worked with you for years and loyalty is part of the difficulty. Keep details that could identify either leader out of any discussion outside the company.

Why does a conflict between two leaders matter beyond the two of them?

Work that crosses between two functions in conflict slows down or stops, and customers often notice first, in a missed date or a question nobody answers. Their teams learn to go around the other function, and the founder spends part of every week as the go-between, taking back decisions the leadership team was built to make.

An acquirer reviewing the company later will ask how the management team works when the owner is not there to settle disputes. A team that settles its disagreements in the weekly meeting, with a record of decisions and owned commitments, answers that question with evidence, as our guide to exit readiness describes.

What should a founder do this week?

  • Count the conversations each leader has had with you about the other this month, and how many included both of them.
  • Stop ruling on private complaints. Send disagreements about the work to the issues list, and take anything that may be a complaint about conduct to your HR adviser or employment attorney first.
  • Meet each leader one to one and collect specific examples.
  • Check the examples against the function map, the handoff between their functions, the scorecard and your own recent instructions.
  • Put the work question on the next weekly agenda, written without names, with the person who decides named in advance.
Key takeaways
  • Find the cause in the work before judging either person: ownership, handoffs, measures, shared resources, open decisions or the founder's own instructions.
  • Stop acting as the go-between. Disagreements about the work go to the issues list or to a meeting with both leaders, and complaints about conduct to your HR adviser or employment attorney first.
  • Write the issue without names, settle who decides first, and end with an owned commitment.
  • When the structure is clear and the conflict continues, talk to each person one to one about the role, judge each on their own conduct, and review the next step with your HR adviser or employment attorney if it persists.
  • Complaints of harassment, discrimination, threats, retaliation or safety go to your HR adviser or employment attorney at once.

The Leadership Scorecard takes ten minutes and shows which parts of your company still run through you.